Product Review: Popular Ballpoint Pens Compared
Ballpoint Pen Comparison Guide
Choosing the right ballpoint pen involves more than simply finding the cheapest option. Writing performance, comfort, affordability, reliability and overall value can make a noticeable difference—especially for students, teachers, office users and anyone who writes for extended periods.
We’ve compared several popular ballpoint pens available from Stationery Arena, including trusted brands such as BIC, Pentel, Pilot, Faber-Castell, Croxley and iWrite, to help you choose a pen that best suits your writing style, application and budget.
Whether you’re looking for an affordable pen for bulk school use, something comfortable for long study sessions, or a fine-point option for neat and precise writing, there is a suitable choice for almost every requirement.
Quick Comparison
| Brand & Model | Tip Size | Grip / Barrel | Writing Style | July 2025 Price* | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BIC Cristal | 1.0 mm | Hexagonal barrel | Smooth standard ballpoint | R6.50 | Everyday writing |
| BIC Orange Fine | 0.8 mm | Hexagonal barrel | Fine, controlled writing | R8.00 | Neat handwriting & forms |
| Croxley Ballpoint | 1.0 mm | Standard barrel | Standard oil-based ballpoint | R3.50 | Bulk, school & general use |
| iWrite Ballpoint | 1.0 mm | Lightweight plastic barrel | Standard ballpoint | R4.00 | General everyday use |
| Faber-Castell Tri-Flow | 1.0 mm | Triangular ergonomic barrel | Smooth, quick-drying writing | R4.50 | Exams, study & long writing sessions |
| Pentel IFeel-It | 1.0 mm | Soft comfort grip | Smooth low-viscosity ink | R7.00 | Comfortable everyday writing |
| Pilot BP-S Fine | 0.7 mm | Slim barrel with grip | Fine, precise oil-based ink | R17.00 | Precision & detailed writing |
Individual Product Reviews
1. BIC Cristal — R6.50
The BIC Cristal remains one of the most recognisable and dependable everyday ballpoint pens available.
Its familiar hexagonal barrel is lightweight and simple to use, while the transparent body allows users to monitor the remaining ink level. The 1.0 mm tip provides a consistent line that works well for everyday school, office and general writing.
BIC also promotes the Cristal for its exceptional ink longevity, with selected models capable of providing up to several kilometres of writing.
Why We Like It
The Cristal does not try to be a premium ergonomic pen. Its strength lies in being simple, consistent, long-lasting and dependable.
Best suited to:
School, office, home and general everyday writing.
Arena Assessment:
A proven all-round performer and one of the strongest options for users who prioritise reliability and value.
2. BIC Orange Fine — R8.00
The BIC Orange Fine offers many of the characteristics associated with the classic BIC design but with a finer 0.8 mm tip.
This makes it particularly suitable for users who prefer smaller handwriting, greater control or a more precise writing line.
Its lightweight hexagonal barrel keeps the familiar BIC feel, while the finer tip makes it useful for completing forms, note-taking and writing in confined spaces.
Why We Like It
A dependable fine-writing alternative for users who enjoy the simplicity of a traditional BIC but prefer greater precision.
Best suited to:
Neat handwriting, forms, detailed notes and smaller writing.
Arena Assessment:
Reliable and precise, although slightly less economical than some of the broader-tip everyday alternatives.
3. Croxley Ballpoint — R3.50
The Croxley Ballpoint is positioned primarily as an affordable everyday writing instrument.
Its biggest strength is its price, making it particularly attractive where pens need to be supplied in larger quantities—for example in classrooms, training environments, offices, events or institutional stationery packs.
While it may not offer the same refined writing feel or ergonomic features as some of the premium alternatives, it provides practical everyday functionality at a very accessible price.
Why We Like It
It offers excellent affordability without unnecessary complexity.
Best suited to:
Schools, classrooms, offices, events and bulk stationery requirements.
Arena Assessment:
A strong budget option where cost, practicality and quantity are the main priorities.
4. iWrite Ballpoint — R4.00
The iWrite Ballpoint provides another economical option for everyday school and office use.
It is lightweight, straightforward and competitively priced, making it suitable for customers purchasing stationery in larger quantities or looking for a practical entry-level pen.
The iWrite range generally focuses on accessible pricing while providing adequate everyday writing performance.
Why We Like It
An affordable, uncomplicated option that provides satisfactory everyday functionality.
Best suited to:
General writing, school stationery packs, offices and bulk supply.
Arena Assessment:
Good basic value and a useful alternative within the entry-level segment.
5. Faber-Castell Tri-Flow — R4.50
The Faber-Castell Tri-Flow stands out strongly in this comparison because it combines an affordable price with several features normally associated with more expensive writing instruments.
Its triangular ergonomic barrel is designed to provide a more natural and comfortable grip, particularly during extended writing sessions.
The 1.0 mm tip produces a smooth writing line, while the ink is designed for quick drying and consistent flow.
These characteristics make the Tri-Flow particularly appealing to students who spend long periods writing during lessons, examinations or study sessions.
Why We Like It
It provides an unusually strong combination of comfort, writing performance and affordability.
Best suited to:
Students, examinations, studying, note-taking and extended writing sessions.
Arena Assessment:
One of the strongest overall value options in this comparison.
6. Pentel IFeel-It — R7.00
The Pentel IFeel-It is designed for users who place greater emphasis on writing comfort and smoothness.
Its low-viscosity ink formulation provides a noticeably fluid writing experience, while the soft rubber grip assists with comfort during prolonged use.
It offers some of the feel associated with a gel-style writing experience while retaining the practical advantages of an oil-based ballpoint pen.
Why We Like It
The combination of smooth ink flow and a comfortable grip makes it particularly enjoyable for frequent writers.
Best suited to:
Students, teachers, professionals and users who write for extended periods.
Arena Assessment:
An excellent mid-range option for users who prioritise writing comfort and smooth performance.
7. Pilot BP-S Fine — R17.00
The Pilot BP-S Fine is the most premium-priced option in this comparison and is aimed at users who value precision and controlled handwriting.
Its 0.7 mm tip provides a fine, crisp writing line, making it particularly useful for smaller handwriting, annotations, detailed note-taking and professional applications.
The transparent barrel allows users to monitor ink levels, while the grip section provides additional control.
The BP-S Fine is also refillable, which can extend the usable life of the pen.
Why We Like It
Excellent control, precision and fine-line performance.
Best suited to:
Detailed writing, professional applications, small handwriting and precise note-taking.
Arena Assessment:
A specialist fine-writing option rather than a budget everyday pen.
Arena Comparative Ratings
Rating Scale
5 = Excellent
4 = Very Good
3 = Good / Standard
2 = Below Average for This Comparison
1 = Limited
| Pen | Writing Performance | Comfort & Ergonomics | Affordability | Value for Money | Versatility | Reliability |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BIC Cristal | 4 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 5 |
| BIC Orange Fine | 4 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 4 | 5 |
| Croxley Ballpoint | 3 | 3 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 4 |
| iWrite Ballpoint | 3 | 3 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 3 |
| Faber-Castell Tri-Flow | 4 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 |
| Pentel IFeel-It | 5 | 5 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 4 |
| Pilot BP-S Fine | 5 | 3 | 1 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
How We Rate the Pens
Writing Performance
Considers smoothness, ink consistency, line quality and overall writing feel.
Comfort & Ergonomics
Considers barrel shape, grip design and suitability for longer writing periods.
Affordability
Compares the selling price of each pen against the other products included in this guide.
A low affordability score does not mean that a pen is poor quality. It simply means that it costs significantly more than the alternatives in this comparison.
Value for Money
Considers the overall balance between price, product quality, performance and features.
Versatility
Measures how well the pen is suited to a range of applications including school, office, professional and everyday writing.
Reliability
Considers consistency of writing performance, product construction, ink delivery and general dependability.
Our Top Picks
| Award | Recommended Pen |
|---|---|
| 🏆 Best Overall Value | Faber-Castell Tri-Flow |
| ⭐ Best Proven Everyday Performer | BIC Cristal |
| 💰 Best Budget Option | Croxley Ballpoint |
| ✍️ Best Writing Comfort | Pentel IFeel-It |
| 🎯 Best Fine & Precision Writing | Pilot BP-S Fine |
| 📚 Best for Exams & Study | Faber-Castell Tri-Flow |
| 🏢 Best Everyday School & Office Pen | BIC Cristal |
Which Ballpoint Pen Should You Choose?
There is no single pen that will necessarily be the best choice for every user.
Your decision should depend on how and where the pen will be used.
If price is your main consideration
The Croxley Ballpoint and iWrite Ballpoint offer some of the most affordable options in the comparison and are especially useful where larger quantities are required.
If you want a dependable everyday pen
The BIC Cristal remains difficult to beat.
Its simple design, established reputation and dependable performance make it suitable for almost every everyday school or office application.
If you write for long periods
The Faber-Castell Tri-Flow and Pentel IFeel-It are the strongest options.
The Tri-Flow’s triangular ergonomic barrel provides excellent grip comfort at a very competitive price, while the Pentel IFeel-It offers an exceptionally smooth writing experience combined with a soft grip.
If you are preparing for exams
The Faber-Castell Tri-Flow is our preferred option because it combines comfort, smooth writing, affordability and practical everyday reliability.
If you prefer fine or precise handwriting
The Pilot BP-S Fine is the specialist option in this comparison.
Its finer 0.7 mm tip makes it particularly suitable for users who prefer controlled, detailed handwriting.
If you are buying for a school or organisation
Cost per unit becomes particularly important when purchasing hundreds or thousands of pens.
In these circumstances, Croxley, iWrite, Faber-Castell and BIC all provide attractive options depending on the balance required between price, writing performance and comfort.
Final Verdict
The ballpoint pen remains one of the simplest stationery products we use every day, but small differences in tip size, ink formulation, barrel shape, grip and price can significantly influence the writing experience.
For overall value, the Faber-Castell Tri-Flow performs exceptionally well because it combines ergonomic design, smooth writing and a very competitive price.
The BIC Cristal remains our preferred traditional all-rounder and continues to be an excellent choice for dependable everyday school and office use.
For users who place a premium on comfort and writing smoothness, the Pentel IFeel-It is particularly impressive.
At the budget end of the range, Croxley and iWrite provide practical options for bulk requirements, while the Pilot BP-S Fine is best suited to users prepared to pay more for fine, precise writing.
Ultimately, the right pen depends on what matters most to you:
Affordability. Comfort. Precision. Smoothness. Reliability.
Fortunately, there is an excellent option available in each category.
Important Notes
* Prices shown are Stationery Arena retail prices recorded in July 2025 and are included for comparative purposes only. Current selling prices may differ.
Product specifications, colours, packaging and availability may change from time to time according to manufacturer or supplier updates.
Arena Ratings represent our comparative assessment of the products based on product specifications, relative pricing, writing characteristics, practical product experience and general customer feedback.
The ratings are intended as a practical buying guide and do not represent independent laboratory test results, manufacturer ratings or formal product certification.
Where a particular specification or feature is important to your purchase decision, we recommend confirming the current product specification before ordering.

